Historical narrations exist on both sides. Critics often cite a few narrations suggesting Abu Talib refused to recite the Kalima (declaration of faith) on his deathbed, while defenders cite his lifelong protection of the Prophet and his explicit verses of poetry praising Islam.
Align the viewpoint with the established scholarly consensus of the Ahl-e-Sunnat wa’l-Jama’at. iman e abu talib book by tahirulqadri pdf fixed